Snow Throwers vs. Snow Plows: Which Winter Tool Is Right for You?

Snow Throwers vs. Snow Plows: Which Winter Tool Is Right for You?

Winter brings its own set of challenges, and one of the biggest is managing snow. Whether it’s a light dusting or a heavy blizzard, clearing snow efficiently is critical to keeping your property safe and accessible. When it comes to tools for the job, the debate often boils down to snow throwers versus snow plows. Each has its strengths and weaknesses, and the best choice depends on your property size, snowfall levels, and personal preferences. This guide will dive deeper into their features to help you make an informed decision.

Understanding Snow Throwers

A snow thrower (often called a snow blower) is a machine designed to scoop up and throw snow away from a desired area. These machines range in size, power, and capabilities, but they’re generally categorized into two main types:

  1. Single-Stage Snow Throwers

    • Lightweight, easy to maneuver, and ideal for areas with light to moderate snowfall.
    • The auger directly touches the ground, making it efficient for clearing paved surfaces but unsuitable for gravel.

  2. Two-Stage Snow Throwers

    • Larger and more powerful, designed to handle deeper, heavier snow.
    • Features both an auger and an impeller, which work together to scoop and propel snow farther away.
    • Ideal for larger properties or areas that experience frequent, heavy snowfalls.

Advantages of Snow Throwers

  • Precision Clearing: Perfect for narrow areas like sidewalks, decks, and pathways where a plow can't reach.
  • Lightweight and Compact: Easier to store in a garage or shed compared to a plow.
  • Affordable: Generally more budget-friendly than snow plow setups, especially for small to medium properties.
  • Versatility: Can handle varying snow depths and types, though heavy ice or packed snow may require multiple passes.

Drawbacks of Snow Throwers

  • Physical Effort: Even self-propelled models require pushing and maneuvering, which can be tiring for larger areas.
  • Slower for Large Areas: Clearing a long driveway or wide parking lot can be time-consuming.
  • Performance Limitations: Struggles with extremely deep snow or icy, compacted conditions.

The Role of Snow Plows

Snow plows are blades mounted to the front of vehicles, such as trucks, SUVs, ATVs, or even riding lawn mowers. Designed for heavy-duty snow removal, they are highly effective for clearing large, open areas.

Advantages of Snow Plows

  • Speed and Efficiency: A snow plow can clear a long driveway, road, or parking lot in a fraction of the time it takes with a snow thrower.
  • Power: Easily handles heavy, deep, or wet snow that might bog down a snow thrower.
  • Convenience: Once installed, operation is straightforward and requires minimal physical effort.
  • Large-Capacity Clearing: Ideal for properties with extensive open areas, such as farms, long driveways, or private roads.

Drawbacks of Snow Plows

  • Initial Cost: Snow plows and the vehicles they attach to are a significant investment.
  • Limited Precision: Difficult to maneuver in tight spaces or on narrow walkways.
  • Storage Space: Requires a sizable area for both the plow and the vehicle it attaches to.
  • Potential Vehicle Wear: Prolonged use can put extra strain on your vehicle’s engine, suspension, and tires.

Factors to Consider When Choosing

  1. Size of the Area to Clear

    • If you’re working with small to medium spaces, such as sidewalks, short driveways, or decks, a snow thrower is a better choice.
    • For large areas, like long driveways, private roads, or parking lots, a snow plow will save time and effort.

  2. Typical Snowfall in Your Area

    • Light to moderate snowfall can be easily handled by a snow thrower.
    • Heavy, frequent snowfalls often require the power and capacity of a snow plow.

  3. Budget

    • Snow throwers are typically more affordable, with options for all budgets.
    • Snow plows have higher upfront costs, especially if you need to purchase or retrofit a vehicle for plowing.

  4. Storage Space

    • Snow throwers are compact and can be stored in a shed or garage.
    • Snow plows require both a vehicle and a dedicated storage area for the blade.

  5. Physical Capabilities

    • A snow plow is less physically demanding, making it ideal for those who might find it difficult to operate a snow thrower for extended periods.

The Hybrid Solution

For property owners with diverse snow-clearing needs, a combination of tools may be the best solution. A snow plow can tackle large areas like driveways and parking lots, while a snow thrower handles walkways, decks, and other tight spaces. While this approach requires a higher initial investment, it ensures you’re prepared for every snow-clearing scenario.

Long-Term Maintenance and Considerations

Regardless of the tool you choose, proper maintenance is key to ensuring longevity and reliability:

  • For Snow Throwers: Regularly check the auger, impeller, and belts. Keep the machine clean and store it in a dry place to prevent rust.
  • For Snow Plows: Inspect the blade for damage, lubricate moving parts, and ensure the mounting system is secure. Keep the plow and vehicle serviced for optimal performance.

Conclusion: Which Is Right for You?

Choosing between a snow thrower and a snow plow boils down to your unique circumstances. If you’re dealing with light to moderate snowfall on a smaller property, a snow thrower is likely your best bet. If you have a large property or frequently face heavy snow, a snow plow offers unmatched efficiency and power. For those with varied needs, combining both tools can provide the perfect solution.

Whatever you choose, investing in the right snow-clearing equipment ensures a safer, more manageable winter season. Stay prepared, stay warm, and let the snowstorm bring beauty—not stress!

Back to blog